In which she investigates bookcovers
Jan. 23rd, 2010 07:49 pmI got some bookvouchers for Christmas (which, to jump to the end of the story, the bookshop hesitated over accepting because the issuing bookshop had neglected to write the date of issue on them. I think they eventually decided to write the date of Christmas on them themselves) so I went to the local bookstore to browse their sf.
Having in mind the controversy over the latest whitewashed Bloomsbury cover (I guess it's progress that they seem to have responded more quickly this time than last? Also it's nice that that's an actual apology. Maybe next time they'll have the sense to think before they publish.) I thought I'd pay attention to the covers.
So, the fantasy and science-fiction section of Scorpio books is about 6 bays of 6 shelves each, plus special displays. Call it about 500 titles give or take? (I didn't include franchise, horror, or manga.) Around about half the covers (give or take) showed people or parts of people. As far as I could tell, these people were:
white;
a silhouette;
white;
slightly tanned;
white;
a skeleton;
honest-to-goodness alabaster;
a shadow in a hood;
white;
a white guy surrounded by black-skinned aliens with guns;
white;
a white mask;
seriously #ffffff white;
a dark-skinned elf attacking two white humans;
white;
a few books with crowd scenes of white people, about half of which scenes thought to include one or two black guys;
white;
white;
and oh yes: white.
No surprises there, then.
But! In those 36 shelves of books - call it about 500 books - I did find 6 whose covers featured a PoC! These were:
(I ended up buying Ragamuffin as well as The Sharing Knife: Passage (which I like to pretend isn't set in the USA, because when I read the first two books I never had a clue it was meant to be anything other than generic pseudo-Euro-fantasyland) and a volume including Lady Susan and the beginnings of The Watsons and Sanditon.)
Having in mind the controversy over the latest whitewashed Bloomsbury cover (I guess it's progress that they seem to have responded more quickly this time than last? Also it's nice that that's an actual apology. Maybe next time they'll have the sense to think before they publish.) I thought I'd pay attention to the covers.
So, the fantasy and science-fiction section of Scorpio books is about 6 bays of 6 shelves each, plus special displays. Call it about 500 titles give or take? (I didn't include franchise, horror, or manga.) Around about half the covers (give or take) showed people or parts of people. As far as I could tell, these people were:
white;
a silhouette;
white;
slightly tanned;
white;
a skeleton;
honest-to-goodness alabaster;
a shadow in a hood;
white;
a white guy surrounded by black-skinned aliens with guns;
white;
a white mask;
seriously #ffffff white;
a dark-skinned elf attacking two white humans;
white;
a few books with crowd scenes of white people, about half of which scenes thought to include one or two black guys;
white;
white;
and oh yes: white.
No surprises there, then.
But! In those 36 shelves of books - call it about 500 books - I did find 6 whose covers featured a PoC! These were:
- Ragamuffin by Tobias S. Buckell [Tor]
- Oathbound and Oathbreakers by Mercedes Lackey [Daw]
- Tapping the Dream Tree by Charles de Lint [Tor]
- Ancient Shores by Jack McDevitt [Eos]
- The Demon and the City by Liz Williams [Nightshade]
(I ended up buying Ragamuffin as well as The Sharing Knife: Passage (which I like to pretend isn't set in the USA, because when I read the first two books I never had a clue it was meant to be anything other than generic pseudo-Euro-fantasyland) and a volume including Lady Susan and the beginnings of The Watsons and Sanditon.)
no subject
Date: 2010-01-23 02:05 pm (UTC)RAGAMUFFIN is good.
no subject
Date: 2010-01-25 06:16 am (UTC)I'll report back on Ragamuffin when I've read it - probably later this week, unless the WIP behaves a lot better than it has been. :-)
no subject
Date: 2010-01-25 11:19 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2010-01-30 05:37 pm (UTC)